Brandon A. Mayo held this tournament to determine the most-liked film of 2009. Held in the spring of 2010.
- The 8-man Mini-Tournament format introduced by "Robot Masters" returns. Here's how it will work:
- This format will repeat itself over 4 weeks, with a different Mini-Tournament each week. The four Mini-tournament winners will compete during Week 5 for the title!
- In the event of a tie, the Metacritic score was used to determine which film would advance to the next round.
- GI Joe: The Rise of Cobra d Hurt Locker (4-2)
- Up d Friday the 13th (2009) (6-0)
- Where the Wild Things Are d Moon (3-2)
- Inglorious Basterds d Paranormal Activity (5-2)
- Up d GI Joe: The Rise of Cobra (4-3)
- Where the Wild Things Are tied Inglorious Basterds (3-3) - WTWTA has a higher Metacritic Score (71-69), advances
- Transformers: Revenge of the Fallen d Ponyo (4-2)
- Avatar d Ong Bak 2 (4-1)
- Black Dynamite d Thirst (5-0)
- Zombieland d X-Men Origins: Wolverine (4-2)
- Drag Me to Hell tied He's Just Not That Into You (4-4) - Drag Me To Hell had a higher Metacritic Score (83-47), advances.
- Star Trek d 2012 (8-0)
- The Hangover d Sherlock Holmes (6-2)
- The Princess and the Frog d Jennifer's Body (4-3)
- District 9 d Terminator Salvation (5-0)
- Taking Woodstock d The Wrestler (4-1)
- Coraline d A Christmas Carol (3-2)
- (500) Days of Summer d Watchmen (3-2)